Did Eisenhower have an affair with a West Cork woman?

hisKay Summersby in 1944

Posted on: 7th April, 2014

Category: The History Corner

Contributor: West Cork People

Samuel Kingston studied history at NUI Galway and has a keen interest in oral and local history. He is also interested in the Irish historical experience abroad especially in Canada and South America. The aim of this column is to tell the stories of West Cork people both famous and forgotten who, through their lives at home or abroad, made an impact on their time.

Above: Kay Summersby in 1944

During World War II, a West Cork woman became a figure of scandal in US military circles. It was believed that she was having an affair with a high ranking US officer; an officer that one day would become leader of the most powerful country in the world. Even today, historians are intrigued by the relationship and the ‘did they, didn’t they’ appeal of the story. Here we examine the gossip and rumours that surrounded the pair.

 Dwight D Eisenhower

Dwight D Eisenhower

In 1943 during the second World War, Dwight D Eisenhower, future President of the United States, became Supreme Commander Allied Expeditionary Force. His chauffeur at this time was Kay Summersby. Kay was born Kathleen Helen MacCarthy-Morrogh. She was born in Inish Beg House, Baltimore, Co. Cork on November 23, 1908.

Kay, a noted beauty, moved to London with her mother following her parent’s separation. She married a British army officer Gordon Thomas Summersby in 1936. By the outbreak of war in 1939 she was a fashion model for Worth, but on hearing Neville Chamberlain’s declaration of war on the wireless on September 3, she signed up the following day with the Motor Transport Corps. In May 1942, she was assigned as driver to the then Major General Dwight D. Eisenhower. Later she became his secretary and spent the rest of the war with him. During this time he was made a five star general and the Supreme Commander. Kay had by this time divorced Summersby. She became engaged to Colonel Richard Arnold with whom she had being having an affair while with Summersby. Arnold was a US Army officer based in North Africa and he was killed while mine clearing in Tunisia in June 1943. His death overlapped with her time as Eisenhower’s chauffeur. It is this relationship with Eisenhower that has caused the most controversy over the years. Speculation over their relationship began from the start. Around the Army Headquarters there were rumours that they were involved in an affair. It is clear that they were very close but how close is a matter of debate.

Evidence suggests that Eisenhower enjoyed spending time with Kay but did the relationship go further? Eisenhower was married to Maime Genena Doud. It seems Maime and Kay had a mutual dislike for one another. Maime clearly distrusted Kay, seeing her as a potential husband snatcher. According to Harry Truman, at one point Eisenhower discussed divorcing Maime and marrying Kay with General George Marshall. Marshall advised that it would probably cost him any chance of a political career. Truman’s version of events may be purposefully misleading as Eisenhower was a political opponent. The contradictions in the story are fascinating, many who worked close to him deny that he was ever involved with Kay yet General Omar Bradley in his autobiography was of the opinion that the two were having an affair and it is noted that President Roosevelt told his daughter Anna that he believed Eisenhower was having an affair with Kay.

The story has many conflicting opinions, not helped by Kay herself. She wrote two books about her life. The first in 1948 made no mention of an affair. Later in 1975 a much more incendiary book was released, this book was ghost written by Barbara Wyden. This book gave a detailed account of the affair. Kay at this stage was dying of Cancer and Eisenhower himself had passed in 1969. Critics of this book claim the details of the affair were merely a fabrication by the ghost writer in an attempt to create a juicy story and boost sales. Eisenhower for his part only mentions Kay once in his own autobiography and that was in a list of his aides. It seems strange that for two people who spent so much time together that she would not receive more mentions but I guess the book served a different agenda. It is clear from the many press photographs that they were close and even Eisenhower’s staunchest supporter will admit that the two were close.

In 1979, the relationship got a new lease of life in the TV min-series – ‘Ike: The War Years’ – this drama focused on the relationship between Eisenhower and Summersby showing how popular the story was in the public imagination. Again, how much of the story was true is impossible to know but no doubt this drama lead to many popular misconceptions about the pair’s relationship. In the drama, Robert Duvall played Eisenhower and Lee Remick played Summersby.

What is true is that Eisenhower helped her become a US citizen and a commissioned officer in the US Women’s Army Corps, which she left in 1947. It also appears that after the war the two never saw each other again. Eisenhower went on to become the 34th President of the United States in 1953. He stayed in office for two terms, being replaced by John F. Kennedy in 1961. He died in 1969. In November 1952, Kay married Reginald Herber Morgan, a stockbroker. They divorced in 1958. She died of cancer at Southampton, Long Island, NY on January 20, 1975 and her ashes brought back to County Cork. Her military awards included the Legion of Merit, Women’s Army Corps Service Medal, European Campaign Medal, World War Two Victory Medal and Army of Occupation Medal.

Latest News Articles:

Issue of childcare a major concern for 72 per cent of female entrepreneurs
Rain, slurry deadlines and housing
Celtic Ross Hotel awarded AA Rosette for Culinary Excellence
St. Joseph’s in Clonakilty looks back on 50 years of educating young girls
‘Operation Transformation’ for Young Beef Farmers
Macra President welcomes publication of EU Young Farmer Survey
Vital role of Focus in the West Cork community highlighted at Open Morning
Clonakilty Food Company opens new production facility in Clonakilty
Beara student one of three Cork students awarded €20,000 scholarship by Naughton Foundation
International success for Skibb rowers

Join us on Facebook

Bandon Walled Town Festival in looking for new ideas!
Would you like to get involved in the 2018 Festival?If you yourself would like to be involved in big or small way
email bandonwalledtown@gmail.com
... See MoreSee Less

11th October, 2017  ·  

Submarines, American Sailors, and the Underwater War in Irish Waters, 1917-1918
by Dr John Borgonovo in The Parish Centre, Clonakilty
on Thursday Oct 26 2017 at 8.30 pm

In 1917, unrestricted submarine warfare by German U-boats brought the United States into WWI and created a crisis in Britain. To defeat the submarine menace, an American naval fleet was dispatched to County Cork, bringing about 10,000 sailors with it. This talk will explain the circumstances of this extraordinary event, and how Cork residents dealt with their unexpected American guests.

Dr John Borgonovo is a lecturer in the School of History at UCC. His publications include Spies, Informers, and the 'Anti-Sinn Féin' Society: The Intelligence War in Cork City, 1920-1921; The Dynamics of War and Revolution: Cork City, 1916-1918; Exercising a close vigilance over their daughters: Cork women, American sailors, and Catholic vigilantes, 1917-18; Something in the Nature of a Massacre: The Bandon Valley Killings Revisited (with Andy Bielenberg). His latest publication (with co-authors John Crowley, Donal Ó Drisceoil and Mike Murphy) is the highly acclaimed and magnificient Atlas of the Irish Revolution. In July of this year, he organised a very successful conference on Winning the Western Approaches - Unrestricted Submarine Warfare and the US Navy in Ireland 1917-1918.
... See MoreSee Less

11th October, 2017  ·  

Apple Juicing Day in Clonakilty next Sunday Sept 30th. All welcome to bring their apples from 2-6pm to the Clonakilty Community Garden (on entrance road to Clonakilty Lodge).

Building on the success of its inaugural 2016 event, local voluntary environmental organisation Sustainable Clonakilty invites people to bring along their apples and press them to extract their own juice to take home, using the group's Apple Press.

Volunteers will be at hand to assist in the procedure. Bring along your apples washed; clean containers to freeze your juice (milk/juice bottles or cartons, plastic bottles with caps); clean, sterilised glass bottles to pasteurise with swing caps or suitable for 26 mm diameter metal cap.

A limited number of new 3 litres juice bags that are suitable for freezing and pasteurising, can be purchased for a nominal fee on the day also.

This is a free community event and donations will be welcome to cover costs.

For further information, please contact Xavier at xavierdubuisson@gmail.com or text at 086/0476124.
... See MoreSee Less

26th September, 2017  ·  

Dúchas Clonakilty's first lecture for the Autumn promises to be of huge interest to all: Emerging from the Shadow of Tom Crean – The Parish Centre, Clonakilty, Thursday September 28th 8.30pm.

Lecture by Aileen Crean O’Brien & Bill Sheppard

In May 2016, Kerry man Tom Crean, along with Ernest Shackleton and four other crew members, landed the James Caird lifeboat on the rocky isle of South Georgia. The navigation of that small boat, across 1500 km through icy winds and towering seas, is regarded as the greatest ever feat of navigation. They then trekked across the forbidding and inhospitable mountains and glaciers of South Georgia to seek help for the rest of their crew, who were left behind on Elephant Island after their ship, the Endurance, was crushed by the Antarctic ice.

One hundred years later, Crean’s grandaughter, Aileen Crean O’Brien, set off with her sons and partner to follow in her grandfather’s footsteps. Join Aileen and Bill to hear of their adventures (and misadventures) on the Southern Ocean and the island of South Georgia.
... See MoreSee Less

7th September, 2017  ·  

Jump to: